The UN rights council voted down a Western-led proposal to hold a discussion about alleged China human rights abuses against Uyghurs in Xinjiang. This was a victory for Beijing, which seeks to avoid further scrutiny.
The 19 against, 17 for, and 11 abstentions defeat is the second in 16 years of council history. It is seen by observers to be a setback to accountability efforts, the West’s moral authority on human right and the credibility and legitimacy of the United Nations.
The motion was brought to you by the United States, Canada, and Britain.
“This is a tragedy. Dolkun Isa (president of the World Uyghur Congress), said that this is a real disappointment. His mother was killed in a camp, and his two brothers are still missing.
He said, “We will not give up, but we are really disappointed at the reaction of Muslim nations.”
The motion was rejected by Qatar, Indonesia and the United Arab Emirates, while Pakistan cited the risk of alienating China. Phil Lynch, director at the International Service for Human Rights, called this voting record “shameful” via Twitter.
Before the vote, China’s envoy warned that the motion would set a precedent for other countries to examine their human rights records.
“Today China is being targeted. Tomorrow, any other developing country will also be targeted,” Chen Xu said, adding that a discussion would lead to “new confrontations.”
China is condemned by the UN report on human rights violations in Xinjiang. But what is its impact?
On August 31, the UN rights office released a long-delayed document that found serious violations of human rights in Xinjiang. This could be considered crimes against humanity and increased pressure on China.
Rights groups accuse Beijing in a series of abuses against Uyghurs. This mainly Muslim ethnic group numbers about 10 million in the western region Xinjiang. They also accuse Beijing in a mass use of forced labor in internment camp camps. The United States has charged China with genocide. Beijing strongly denies any abuses.
This is the first time the rights record of China, a powerful permanent member of the Security Council, has been on the agenda. The item has sparked divisions. A diplomat stated that China was putting “enormous pressure” on states to support China.
Even though Thursday’s outcome was not favorable, countries like Germany, the United States, and Britain pledged to continue working towards accountability.
However, activists claimed that the defeat of a so-called limited motion, which did not seek an investigation, would make putting it back on the agenda difficult.
UN report on China’s Uyghurs – What you need to know
Marc Limon, Universal Rights Group, stated that it was a “serious mistake calculation”, citing the timing of a Western-led move for action against Russia.
He said, “It’s an important blow for the credibility council and a clear win for China.” “Many developing nations will see it as an adjustment away Western predominance within the UN human rights system.”
Many poor countries of the 47-member council were left with political dilemmas by the event. They are afraid to publicly challenge China in fear of jeopardizing investments.
Others may have wanted to avoid future scrutiny.