Entertainment
What the research says about the toys vs. tech plot in ‘Toy Story 5’ : NPR

The much anticipated summer movie Toy Story 5 features a battle between toys and tech — a plot likely to resonate with parents who see the pull of digital devices in their kids’ lives, especially during the summer.
And that’s not just a parental perception: Research clearly shows that screen time goes up dramatically during the summer.
“For kids, 7 to 12, they are using and spending more time on their screens, about 30% more, which is equivalent to about four more hours per week compared to school time,” says Lauren Lee, a psychologist at Aura, an online safety company that compiled a very detailed report about kids’ online lives based on data from nearly 30,000 devices.
For the latest stories on the science of healthy living, subscribe to NPR’s Health newsletter.
Aura gathered information through its parental control app that accesses children’s and parents’ devices and through surveys with parents and children around the country. It found that 75% of children ages 7 to 11 years old said that they would rather watch videos than play with toys.
It’s a statistic at the heart of the Toy Story 5 plot, where 8-year-old Bonnie starts to ignore her beloved toys after her parents give her a “Lilypad” tablet that’s the new social capital.
“Summer is a particularly vulnerable period for higher screen use,” says pediatrician Dr. Jason Nagata, who was not involved in the Aura study. Nagata, who researches online behaviors of children and teens at the University of California, San Francisco, says the Aura research jibes with what previous studies have shown. In the absence of the structure and routine of school days, it is easy to reach for devices.
Higher screen time during summers is the norm now
The new study gives a degree of granularity, not just on the time children and teens are spending online, but on what they are doing — scrolling, playing video games and socializing virtually. (A virtual social group is a big part of the Toy Story 5 plot — but no spoilers here!) .
For teens, screen time goes up by 15% during the summer compared to the school year, the report finds. While younger kids are spending much of their time on devices watching YouTube videos or playing on the video gaming platform Roblox, teens are spending more time on social media apps, according to the new report.
Nearly 70% of children are on their devices by mid-afternoon, and 1 in 10 remain active on their devices at midnight.
“We are seeing nighttime messaging rates more than doubling across all age groups compared to the fall,” says Lee.
The new Toy Story movie also portrays this, with Bonnie, staying up late on her new tablet, and reaching for it first thing in the morning.
More screens, worse sleep and mood
Studies also illustrate the negative health impacts of such high screen time during summers. The Aura report finds that as the summer wears on, one in three children score low on Aura’s Digital Wellbeing Index, which correlates digital behaviors with a range of health parameters, including sleep, mood, isolation and their ability to regulate emotions. The company scores children on this index based on surveys of kids and parents as well as their screen habits.
“Time that is generally spent on screens is often displacing sleep, physical activity or outdoor time,” says Nagata.
And those factors — adequate sleep, time outdoors, physical activity, in-person socializing with friends and family — are really important for the health and wellbeing of children, he says, especially during the summer when they aren’t at school being engaged, active and interacting with others.
Kids don’t want to be stuck to their screens all summer
There’s some good news, too. The Aura report shows that kids have some self-awareness around tech: More than half of the children and teens surveyed recognize that too much time on screens isn’t good for them, and more ranked spending time with friends (36%) and going outside (24%) higher than using a tablet (20%).
That’s been shown in other studies, too, says Nagata. “Many children and teens themselves report that they actually don’t want to be glued to their phones over the summer,” he says. “It’s just oftentimes, they’re a little bit bored.”
Screens are easy to reach for when bored, and many apps are designed to keep people hooked for extended periods, with constant notifications and alerts.
So, as kids around the country start their summer vacations, how can parents ensure that they don’t spend their days sucked into their devices?
1. Give them something else to do. Fun and structure are the buzzwords.
Parents should try to provide fun alternatives to screens, Nagata suggests. “If you’re just saying, ‘Oh, you have to limit your screen use to 1 or 2 hours a day without providing fun alternatives, it can be really hard if the kid is still stuck at home and kind of bored,” he says.
Nagata suggests activities that offer a “physical barrier” to devices, like swimming.
“I try to take my daughter swimming every weekend over the summers, and the pool has become our special father-daughter place,” he says. “And it’s also screen free. You cannot physically bring phones or devices into the pool.”
He also recommends summer camps. A 2023 survey by the American Camp Association found that 90% of summer camps banned cell phones and tablets.
“Camps that especially provide opportunities for physical activity, outdoor play and opportunities for stronger relationships and social interactions may be especially beneficial for kids,” he says.
For kids less interested in sports or physical activities, there are art, music and cooking camps, too. Niki Cordell runs a summer camp in Chicago called Junior Chefs Kitchen. Kids get hands-on experience cooking two recipes every day, and go to the park for about an hour. Once a week, they visit various restaurants in the city.
“Not all kids are super sporty, so this gives them the ability to build confidence and life skills in a different setting,” says Cordell. Kids in her camp often go home wanting to recreate the recipes they learned, she says.
Organizing days around trips to the library or park, and taking advantage of community organizations like the Boys & Girls Clubs of America are lower cost ways to give summer days more structure.
2. Let the kids have a say. Try a “family bingo” approach.
Engage your kids in planning for days when they don’t have camp or other activities, says Merve Lapus, vice president of education, outreach and engagement for Common Sense Media, an advocacy organization.
“It’s actually really important to just have that discussion with the kids and recognize that it’s very easy to get lost in screens, but we want to really be in agreement that this is something we’re going to try and do together,” says Lapus. He also recommends that parents do activities with their children.
“For my own teenager, this is going to be the year that she learns about driving,” he says. “So we’re going to spend a lot of time on things that are going to be very practical for their next stage [of life].”
Cordell, who is also a mother of three, says she and her children create a “family bingo sheet,” with various activities. “It could be kayaking or water balloon fight day,” she says. “Then we put a bunch of different activities in a jar.”
When her kids get bored, they pick out an activity from the jar and do it. For this summer, one of her children suggested creating little characters out of shaving cream, says Cordell. “I was like, ‘I’ve never heard of that before, but let’s go for it!'”
Summer lists are also important to Simmons Hanson, a teacher and mother of three children, ages 8, 11 and 13.
“For years and years we have made a summer list,” says Hanson, who lives in Washington D.C. “Sometimes it’s big things on the list, like camps or vacations, trips to the beach. But it’s also little things like a double-ice-cream-day.”
Then there are activities that Hanson’s middle child thinks of when she’s bored that aren’t already on the family summer list. Instead of writing them down, the 11-year-old Sallie Chappell Hanson says she files away the ideas in her brain for later.
“I think that your brain is like a catalog,” she says. “Instead of saving files, it can save ideas.”
Some of her ideas include entrepreneurial endeavors like selling lemonade or handmade bracelets in her neighborhood. Other ideas involve arts and crafts projects, or playing imaginary games with her 8-year-old sister.
3. Set some rules for the whole family (and follow them!)
“The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends implementing a family media plan,” says Nagata. That’s an “individualized set of guidelines for your household.”
That media plan should include times — like meal times and bedtimes — and places — like bedrooms — that are free of devices for the whole family.
“That means devices don’t need to be on the table when we’re having a meal together, if that’s something that families are able to do,” suggests Lapus. “It’s really just important to recognize what are your family values and how do you center those?”
“We started to have some rules around limiting screen time because the kids were getting really grumpy after hours and hours of screen time,” says Hanson.
And they revisit those rules at the beginning of the summer.
“Our family is sometimes managed by quirky rules, like you can have screen time when it rains,” she says. “And sometimes it’s determined by it’s a long day after soccer camp and everybody needs to cool off and I need to make dinner. And so then that becomes screen time.”
Her kids share an iPad and a Chrome Book, and each kid uses the devices for different things based on their stage of development. All her kids love listening to podcasts, she says, but they are often doing other things while listening to them.
4. Check your own screen use — and share your struggles.
Nagata also recommends modeling healthy screen use, especially as recent research suggests that children tend to mirror screen use by parents. Hanson agrees.
“We as parents, we have always modeled and narrated a lot of things around us,” she explains.
“Even from when the kids were very young, narrating and modeling things about our choices – about why we choose to go here or there, or why we choose to wear this. Tech choice is no different.”
It helps raise awareness in her children about the drawbacks of excessive technology use, and creates an ongoing conversation about it in her family.
Hanson used to regularly scroll through Instagram, she says. “And the kids love to look over my shoulder and look at Instagram,” she says. “We would get stuck scrolling.”
But recently, she realized such excessive scrolling through her feed was having a negative impact on her own mood.
“I could feel myself getting grumpy and getting short tempered with the kids, when I was trying to look at Instagram and parent at the same time,” explains Hanson. “It’s not a great combo.”
So, she took Instagram off of her phone, and explained to her kids why she did that.
“Those sorts of choices continue to be necessary to explain as they grow up and are paying attention to everything that we are doing as parents,” she says. “It feels really important to guide them in their choices with our own behavior.”
Entertainment
New movies to watch this weekend: See ‘Toy Story 5’ in theaters, rent ‘Pressure,’ stream ‘Project Hail Mary’ on MGM+
Welcome to Trust Me, I Watch Everything, a weekly guide to all the new movies out each Friday and where to find them. This week’s buzziest release is Toy Story 5, the latest entry in the iconic 31-year-old Disney-Pixar franchise.
If you’d rather have a movie night at home, you can rent or buy Pressure, the star-studded WWII D-Day movie that elicits tension about a weather forecast.
And on streaming services you’re likely already paying for, the Ryan Gosling sci-fi vehicle Project Hail Mary, one of the year’s biggest box-office hits, is coming to MGM+.
Intrigued? Let’s get into it!
What to watch in theaters
Movies newly available to rent or buy
Movies newly available on streaming services you may already have
🎥 What to watch in theaters
The biggest release: Toy Story 5
Why you should see it: Toy Story 5 is here and set to become the biggest movie of the summer at the box office, 31 years after the original introduced the concept of a feature-length, entirely computer-animated movie to the big screen. It continues the storied franchise’s tradition of laughs, tears and, frankly, just being damn good movies that both kids and adults can enjoy.
When Bonnie receives a Lilypad tablet as a gift and becomes obsessed, Buzz, Woody, Jessie and the rest of the gang have to go head-to-head with the all-new threat to playtime.
What’s most impressive here is the way the movie understands the multi-pronged threat that technology poses to children: how it changes the very nature of “play” to the point where playing with toys is discouraged, and why using a tablet to communicate with your classmates as the only way to connect, especially for shy kids, can be a big disadvantage.
It took becoming a parent for me to realize that every single one of these movies is, quite obviously, about parenting. In case that wasn’t made clear enough, there’s a shot toward the end of the film that makes it fact, with Bonnie’s parents and Buzz and Woody positioned so we’re watching both sets of “parents” react.
It may not reach the highs of the original trilogy, but it has a renewed sense of purpose that wasn’t quite present in the fourth entry. By focusing on the very real threats children face from our societal push toward “smart” toys and the proliferation of iPads and tablets, Toy Story 5 more than justifies its existence, even if the messaging stops short of going full “analog is better, and tech is inherently bad for children’s development.” Reminding children that nothing can replace face-to-face contact, and that simply hanging out, playing, and using your imagination is the best way to form community, is an important lesson, particularly relevant today. But there is some cognitive dissonance required when the movie tries to have its cake and eat it too about tech’s invasion into our lives — they have to sell Lilypad, after all.
What other critics are saying: It’s getting mostly positive reviews! Nick Schager at the Daily Beast writes: “A cute and funny sequel that treads well-worn territory and yet manages to elicit its fair share of waterworks, it’s not the series’ best but, in most respects, is still better than the rest.” TheWrap’s William Bibbiani, meanwhile, calls it “enjoyable but repetitive.”
How to watch: Toy Story 5 is now playing in theaters nationwide.
Get tickets
The Death of Robin Hood: The latest film from Michael Sarnoski, the writer/director of the beloved Nicolas Cage film Pig, provides his own take on the iconic character. Grappling with his violent past, Robin Hood (Hugh Jackman) finds himself gravely injured after a battle that he thought would be his last. He soon gets a chance at salvation when he meets a mysterious woman and a young girl. I’m technically on vacation and missed this one, but it’s getting strong reviews, with critics calling it both gratuitously violent and thoughtful.
Get tickets
💸 Movies newly available to rent or buy
The biggest release: Pressure
Why you should consider it: Pressure will either sound fascinating to you, or incredibly boring, and however you feel about it going in will, in fact, determine what you think of it.
In the tense 72 hours before D-Day, and with the fate of the free world hanging in the balance, the film follows General Dwight D. Eisenhower (Brendan Fraser) and Captain James Stagg (Andrew Scott) as they face an impossible choice — launch the largest and most dangerous seaborne invasion in history or risk losing the war altogether.
Essentially, it’s an entire movie relying on the tension of a weather forecast. It’s a movie tailor-made for the stereotypical “dad” viewer, who stand a little too close to the TV and watch movies with their hands on their hips, rapt. It combines two undeniably “dad” interests — World War II and the weather — and attempts to deliver a rousing spectacle.
Despite a terrific lead performance from Scott — and a hammy big one from Brendan Fraser — the movie is simply boring. It’s a lot of people talking about how sure or unsure they are about the weather, and the tension isn’t quite there, given that we all know the actual day D-Day happened. It’s one of the most famous dates on the calendar!
Pressure may satisfy those who think a movie about a WWII-era weather forecast sounds like riveting entertainment, but the rest of us might find it more suitable for background fodder during a nap.
What other critics are saying: Reviews are more mixed. AP’s Jocelyn Noveck writes: “Fraser’s Eisenhower is physically imposing and stubborn too. … But he’s frankly less interesting than Scott’s multifaceted Stagg, a character and performance that elevates an otherwise efficient, well-made war movie into something more intriguing.” IndieWire’s Alison Foreman writes: “There are hints of a far better movie peeking out from [director Anthony] Maras’s dull weather drama, and the Australian director nearly finds it on numerous occasions.”
How to watch: Pressure is now available to rent or buy on Apple TV, Prime Video and other VOD platforms.
Rent or buy
But that’s not all…
Busboys: Extremely successful podcaster Theo Von joins up with comedian/actor David Spade in this independent film that is entirely written, produced and self-financed by its two stars, who put up $3 million of their own money. A pair of clueless friends see becoming waiters as the answer to all their problems, and hijinks ensue. It wasn’t screened for critics in advance, but I’ll be catching up with it soon! Rent or buy.
Deep Water: Renny Harlin bounces back from his awful trilogy of Strangers sequels with this shark attack/plane crash double disaster flick. A group of international passengers on a flight from Los Angeles to Shanghai is forced to make an emergency landing in shark-infested waters. The terrified group must work together and overcome their differences if they hope to escape their sinking plane and the frenzy of sharks drawn to the wreckage. The plane crash sequence itself is the highlight, arguably one of the most and most drawn-out crash sequences I’ve ever seen, but once they’re fending off sharks, the movie’s budgetary constraints start to show. Aaron Eckhart’s hammy performance will either work for you, or it won’t.Rent or buy.
📺 Movies newly available on streaming services you may already have
The biggest release: Project Hail Mary
Why you should consider it: Ryan Gosling and his ample reserve of charming movie-star energy help power the extremely familiar Project Hail Mary to recommendable status, despite some elements that occasionally get in the way.
Science teacher Ryland Grace (Gosling) wakes up on a spaceship light-years from home with no recollection of who he is or how he got there. As his memory returns, he begins to uncover his mission: to solve the riddle of the mysterious substance that is causing the sun to die out. He must call on his scientific knowledge and unorthodox ideas to save everything on Earth from extinction. But an unexpected friendship may mean he doesn’t have to do it alone.
If it sounds like you’ve seen this all before, that’s because Project Hail Mary is essentially a mash-up of several popular works of science fiction, including the decade-old Matt Damon flick The Martian, which was based on a book written by Andy Weir, the same guy who wrote the bestseller on which Project Hail Mary is based.
Gosling does commendable work throughout, carrying the movie on his back so thoroughly that I hope he checked in with a chiropractor after filming. It’s essentially a one-man show, and he does an excellent job of guiding the audience through it all. By the time a spider-like rock creature is introduced, he plays off his scene-partner puppet with gusto. Sandra Hüller of Anatomy of a Fall fame is also great in her scenes on Earth as the no-nonsense head of the expedition.
The movie pays lip service to classic sci-fi films like Close Encounters of the Third Kind while simultaneously stealing the plot of Christopher Nolan’s masterpiece Interstellar. It ultimately morphs into an E.T.-style story about a human befriending an alien creature and discovering we’re not all that different. There’s also a spacewalk scene that reminded me of Gravity. No, you’re not crazy to reference Armageddon or even Cast Away.
In addition to its plot similarities to The Martian, Project Hail Mary also emulates that film’s Obama-era hopecore ideal that if all the smartest people in the world put aside their differences and work together, nothing is impossible. Come to think of it, that sounds a lot like Arrival too. Also, am I the only person who remembers that bad Netflix movie Spaceman, starring Adam Sandler, from a few years ago? How did we end up with two movies about a guy talking to a spider-like creature in outer space?! That movie must’ve ripped off this book!
Anyway, as the movie goes on and on (and on and on, it ends about 15 times), it’s as if you’re watching the filmmakers attempt to convince themselves as well as the audience that the movie is an important work of sci-fi grandeur on the level of classics like 2001: A Space Odyssey, which it’s somehow longer than.
Filmmakers Phil Lord and Chris Miller have good reason to want to prove themselves — they became in-demand after the popularity of their 21 Jump Street reboot and The Lego Movie, but were famously fired mid-movie while making Disney’s Han Solo Star Wars spinoff before beloved director Ron Howard took over.
On a technical level, the movie looks great; I was especially taken with the alien creature’s ship. It’s the storytelling that falters. The movie aims to please so much that it undercuts any potential drama; it’s preordained that everything will work out fine. It’s so desperate to entertain that it constantly breaks the tension with jokes, which gets irritating, even if Gosling is good at selling it.
Part of the problem here is the flashback structure, which kills momentum by doubling back to fill us in on the story, which isn’t all that compelling because we’ve all seen the movies it’s ripping off. It is also a reminder of the incongruity between Gosling’s character as presented in space and as portrayed on Earth, where he’s a meek science teacher.
Despite the movie constantly joking about his lack of space captain abilities, he’s able to fly the ship when the movie needs him to, and there’s little point in spending so much time with his character refusing the mission. I’ve seen the future — he’s already there!
In short, Project Hail Mary mostly delivers as an IMAX-sized spectacle, anchored by Gosling’s terrific work, despite the movie’s increasingly derivative nature and protracted finale. And now you can find out how it plays at home on your television.
What other critics are saying: It’s well-reviewed, which is part of why I felt I had to level-set expectations. There’s something so try-hard about it to me! David Fear at Rolling Stone writes: “Gosling can actually sell us on an everyman thrust into extraordinary circumstances while still beguiling us with old-school snap, crackle, and pop.” Mashable’s Kristy Puchko writes: “Imagine The Martian meets Half Nelson meets E.T., and you’ll get some idea of the mirthful mash-up that is Project Hail Mary.”
How to watch: Project Hail Mary is now streaming on MGM+.
Watch on MGM+
Another great option: Voicemails for Isabelle
Why you should watch it: A romantic-comedy tearjerker that revolves around a character’s recently deceased sister shouldn’t work, but Voicemails for Isabelle absolutely does, thanks to strong performances and smart, clever utilization of rom-com tropes.
A young woman’s hilariously confessional voicemails to her late sister are unknowingly redirected to a stranger, who begins to fall in love from afar. It plays like a modern update of You’ve Got Mail with a tragic twist, yet it remains charming and funny despite the heaviness.
Zoey Deutch is wonderful, as always, in the lead role, and Nick Robinson does a great job navigating the complexities of the situation his character finds himself in. It’s one of those movies that reminds you that formulaic material can be a comfort, if executed properly.
Voicemails for Isabelle will make you laugh, cry and swoon over a romance that, in lesser hands, could’ve come off incredibly cheesy. Writer/director Leah McKendrick, whose previous feature, Scrambled, is also worth a look, proves herself an exciting new voice to keep an eye on.
What other critics are saying: It’s getting solid reviews. AV Club’s Caroline Siede calls it “the best Netflix dramedy in years.” William Bibbiani at TheWrap was a bit more restrained: “The enthusiasm comes across, and it’s infectious even when the movie doesn’t quite work. Which is most of the time.”
How to watch: Voicemails for Isabelle is now streaming on Netflix.
Watch on Netflix
But that’s not all…
How to Make a Killing: This remake of the 1949 black comedy Kind Hearts and Coronets stars Glen Powell as a blue-collar man disowned at birth by his obscenely wealthy family who will stop at nothing to reclaim his inheritance, no matter how many relatives stand in his way. Margaret Qualley steals the show as the sexy, menacing femme fatale; anytime she’s onscreen, the movie is electric. When she’s not, it’s fairly limp, and the energy shift to lame broad-caricature comedy about rich failsons that Powell ends up taking out one by one is always disappointing. In this case, you’re better off watching the original, in which Alec Guinness portrays all the victims, a far more clever take on the aristocracy’s borderline inbred nature. Now streaming on HBO Max.
Never Change: If you enjoy comedy with several jokes a minute and a lot of very funny people, this very silly movie might be for you. In 2008, the graduating class of North Meadows High School had their senior year cut short by a devastating tornado. Now in their mid-30s, they’re being forced to return home and finish high school once and for all. It’s got a Wet Hot American Summer-style penchant for silliness and a premise ripe for taking advantage of that. It won’t be for everyone, but those who find it funny will find it very, very funny. Now streaming on Hulu.
That’s all for this week! We’ll see you next Friday, just in time for Supergirl.
Entertainment
Oliver Tree’s mom breaks silence after singer vowed not to share wealth with family
Oliver Tree’s mom, Christine Begin Nickell, is mourning the loss of her son after he died in a helicopter crash on June 14.
“Our dear son Oliver, you made this world a better place. We are so proud of you. RIP,” she wrote on her Facebook page, along with three broken heart emojis, on Thursday.
Nickell also shared a never-before-seen photo of her son, who looked unrecognizable without his signature bangs and long hair.
Many friends and family reached out in the comment section to offer their condolences, with one person saying, “We were fortunate to have known Oliver as a ‘little’ boy to a young and talented exceptional artist. Thank you to both of you, Christine and Jesse, for having tortured such a wonderful family. Rest in peace, Oliver Tree. Rudy-Virginia.”
“You raised an amazing man who inspired and left his mark on so many people. He is so sorely missed. Sending you and your family all my love,” another person wrote.
Meanwhile, another added, “May you find peace. we are so saddened by this. You are all in our thoughts. He was a spirit to be reckoned with for sure. He helped so many people through his art. So much to be proud of.”
Just two months ago, Nickell had shared a photo of Tree hugging his mom and dad, Jesse, after they attended his show at the Red Rocks Amphitheater in Colorado.
And in February, she shared the poster announcing Tree’s “The World’s First World Tour,” which would take him to Mexico, Chile, Argentina and Brazil, where he ultimately died.
On Sunday, two helicopters crashed in Recreio dos Bandeirantes, in the Southwest zone of Rio de Janeiro, with the “I Miss You” singer being identified as one of six casualties. He was 32.
Per CNN, two helicopters collided early in the morning while flying over an electric vehicle yard and set fire to at least 20 cars due to the collision.
Tree had just performed a show in São Paulo on June 6 and was scheduled to pick up his tour in Lisbon on July 13.
His mom’s comments came two months after Tree vowed not to leave any money to his family after his passing.
“I don’t believe that any of the wealth, or the things that get made from it, is mine,” the “Life Goes On” singer said on the April 24 episode of the “Zach Sang Show.”
“So when I die, my will is set up that when I pass, my family, no one’s going to get a penny,” he added before insisting that if he had “a wife or kids or anything, [they’re] not getting a f–king penny.
“I’ll get my kids through college. That’s the agreement,” he continued. “But there’s not going to be a silver spoon. The idea is, when I die, all the money is going to go back to artists.”
Instead, he wanted his money to go toward “the physical making of art” rather than education after setting up a foundation called Dr. Oliver Tree’s Art Grants for Baby Geniuses to collect the interest from his music.
“You’re not allowed to buy equipment with the money. You’re not allowed to go get education and schooling with the money,” he said. “You have to physically hire people to physically produce stuff — and you’re allowed to rent equipment to make things.
“I have basically a committee that I’ve set up when I pass — and I plan to do it while I’m alive — where basically everyone will vote on who the money goes to each year.”
Entertainment
John Early’s Secret Is Total Commitment
John Early has one of the most expressive faces of any actor working today. You’ve almost certainly seen it. The 38-year-old comedian, born and raised in Nashville, has had many small breaks into the zeitgeist over the past decade or so. His voice might also be familiar to you: He’s worked on a gamut of animated shows including Bob’s Burgers, Tuca & Bertie, The Great North, and Summer Camp Island (a personal favorite). He appeared most recently and prominently in the A24 comedy Eternity, but also in Tim Robinson’s I Think You Should Leave, Julio Torres’ Los Espookys, and the wildly underrated HBO series Search Party. It’s this latter show where I first saw Early, not by actually watching an episode, but from clips circulating on Twitter.
Indeed, this is how I came to be familiar with several of Early’s peers, alt comedians like Jo Firestone, Patti Harrison, and Conner O’Malley, whose brilliant, keenly observed work seems to live timelessly on the internet. But Early has always communicated an old soul, duly inspired by his friends and colleagues, but also the movement and spectacle of Bob Fosse, the melodrama of cult classics like Showgirls, and, as evidenced by his directorial debut masterpiece, ’80s TV movies like Kate’s Secret.
Early’s film, Maddie’s Secret, is not a retelling of that 1986 film, which follows a bulimic woman as she faces pressures both familial and psychological, though there are commonalities: a blonde lead, an eating disorder, the anxiety of a life lived under scrutiny. But Maddie’s Secret is something entirely unique and surprisingly moving, a melodrama following the eponymous Maddie (Early), a dishwasher at the fictional Conde Nast magazine Gourmaybe, who is one day thrown into the spotlight when a video of one of her homemade dishes goes viral. As her fame increases, so does the burden of keeping Maddie’s harrowing past trauma, and the eating disorder that manifests because of it, at bay. In Maddie’s Secret, comedy and severity go hand in hand. Humor lives alongside and within the very real drama performed and staged by Early and his longtime professional partner, Kate Berlant. Maddie’s Secret showcases not only Early’s many talents as a performer, but his instincts as a filmmaker, one deeply attuned to the inner lives of women in friendship and in crisis.
I talked to Early over the phone about his new film. Among other things, we discussed sincerity, the line between vulgarity and crudeness, what it means to commit to a performance, a concept, a way of going about one’s life, and, of course, Showgirls. Our conversation has been lightly edited.
Congrats on making the movie of the year.
It’s official?!
It’s official, yeah. I just got a text about it.
Oh my god.
There was an element in this movie that I was … it’s not that I was worried about it, but I was curious as to how you would frame the bulimia. But you never show Maddie actually vomiting; it’s always before or after. Can you talk a bit about that? It’s a dignifying choice.
There was never any question for me. When I came up with this premise, I came up with it very quickly. This movie was made very, very quickly. That was by design. I wanted to make something kind of crude, not disgusting, but elementally kind of crude and blunt and direct and expressive. I figured if I just made it very quickly, that would be a good way for something exciting to happen that I maybe didn’t have that much control over.
But it was a strange thing where I was like, Oh, I’ve chosen this premise that, on paper, seems provocative. And it of course is, and there’s clearly some part of me that needs to be provocative. But I also think that’s part of what gives this movie a special kind of charge. There’s always this potential to be provocative. At every point in the movie, it could tip over into something that’s mocking or kind of suffocatingly ironic or even grotesque. I personally don’t think we tip over into that side. I mean, it’s not for me to be the judge of, but that was what I was trying to do, and instead to always protect it and keep it sincere. I don’t think the emotion would be felt if that potential wasn’t right next to it.
I think this is a perfect example: You read the logline, you see the trailer, you know it’s about bulimia, you’re expecting there to be some sort of scene where you see her vomiting. But I think it’s more interesting to not do that. Also, I couldn’t be less interested. I wasn’t holding back some sick desire to show it: I did not want to see that at all on screen. I would rather die than people describe this movie as like, queer body horror. I can’t take another queer body horror movie!
[laughs] Me neither.
I can’t take it. Bulimia interested me on a symbolic level. It interested me on a genre level. I just immediately, within like four seconds of writing this movie, felt a very intense protectiveness over Maddie, and I wanted to preserve her dignity. I didn’t want to see her in that situation.
That’s of a piece with how you’ve previously talked about irony, sincerity, camp, the line between these things. Maddie’s Secret is a movie where there is no line. I feel like a crucial part of that is the fact that you start with Maddie as a character, as a woman, first. Everything spirals outward from there. I wonder if you can talk a little bit about performance, acting, embodiment of character. I forgot it was you playing her about 10 minutes into the movie. Ironically, I was thinking of your “Rock the Boat” video during this film. Obviously for the dancing, but also your total commitment to movement and persona. It’s where the humor comes from.
I’ve played women before. I’ve done a lot of characters for a long time where the goal was a certain kind of realism, a kind of lace-front realism. I love broad sketch comedy, and I do it and I don’t bring it up pejoratively.
It’s more that I’ve always been compelled by doing something that could be seen as sketch comedy, but filming it in a way that actually allows for a certain kind of cinematic feeling, of emotion and nuance. I really believed that we could achieve that. I really believed that if you just gave me five minutes, that people will buy into this illusion, and that if they buy into this illusion, if their hearts are open to me as Maddie, then their hearts will be open to the rest of the stylistic extremes of this movie.
People have said to me that they forget that it’s me, and that’s so exciting. Because, who cares about me? That’s the problem too. I’m so sick of seeing the same fucking actors in everything, the same actors who are on the very, very short list of people who can get things financed. I want to see new faces. It’s also, like—I really love fully transforming, you know. Something like dance or something like playing a woman, these are very extreme things physically. They require you to fully commit. I deliberately am drawn to things like that because they don’t let you off the hook. In order to pull them off, you have to fully dance. And in order to play Maddie, I couldn’t send it up. If I were playing someone who looked like me, I can see it kind of deflating the tension. I need the gunpoint, for some reason.
Was Maddie always a woman?
No. Once I was writing the script, she was a woman. When I first thought of the premise, I was like, It’s a gay food influencer. He was bulimic too, but I was being pulled by these women’s pictures, these eating movies, these melodramas.
The archetype came first. First it was just: ingenue. So there was a certain rhythm of speaking, a certain attitude. And when I was trying to put that in a gay man’s body, as in my own, it just wasn’t working. I would love to change that, or I would love to try to push through it, but I wasn’t ready to do that, I guess. It felt too ironic.
That feels fair, though.
It felt more ironic to play a gay guy who had this kind of sunny disposition. It felt like I was doing something caustic, and I can’t explain why. The character being a girl was just pounding at the door and I was like, Yeah. That seemed kind of scary, but the second I opened the door, all of this color and emotion and expressiveness just rushed in. It was beautiful. The second I allowed myself to do what I actually wanted to do, it went from being this kind of ratty, angry movie to being something full of feeling.
There’s obviously the Showgirls element. I’m based in and from Vegas, where there’s that line between irony and commitment. Maybe what gets lost in certain reappraisals of Showgirls is the fact that Paul Verhoeven is, like, not joking. [laughs]
There’s footage of Paul Verhoeven directing those actors where he’s like … [mimes pulling exaggerated faces] He’s really encouraging them to be very stylistically kind of operatic and orgasmic, you know? Obviously Elizabeth Berkeley is taking that direction and is going there. It makes people laugh, I think, out of discomfort, and I think the laugh after is the reaction that you have right before you cross the threshold.
Absolutely.
That, to me, is almost the whole point of this movie. I wanted there to be something very moving that I was holding up in front of the audience, that they have time to approach with laughter. They might be kicking and screaming but a good portion of them, I felt in screenings, do cross the threshold and yield to the emotion in the movie. If people don’t cross the threshold and want to keep laughing the whole time, that is totally OK, and there’s certainly things to laugh at through the very end.
But I do think that my experience is, often when I’m cracking up at something, it’s because I’m uncomfortable.
Well, especially in the case of Maddie’s Secret, laughter feels good after you let yourself cry.
And crying feels a little bit better after you’ve kind of opened your lungs from laughing.
Entertainment
Tay Keith, Grammy-nominated producer, found dead in Nashville at 29
Grammy-nominated record producer Tay Keith was found dead in his Nashville apartment on Thursday, the city’s police department said on social media. He was 29 years old.
He was found dead by officers performing a welfare check, the Metro Nashville Police Department said. Police did not say what spurred the welfare check.
An autopsy will determine his cause of death, the department said. No foul play is suspected.
Keith, whose birth name is Brytavious Chambers, worked with music superstars including Beyonce, Drake and Eminem. He had two Grammy nominations for Best Rap Song: one for 2019’s “Sicko Mode” by Travis Scott, Drake, Big Hawk and Swae Lee, and the other for Drake and 21 Savage’s 2024 song “Rich Flex.” Keith was a producer on both songs.
Other music he produced included Drake’s “Nonstop” and Eminem’s “Not Alike.”
Keith spent much of his life in Tennessee. He was from Memphis and attended Middle Tennessee State University, according to CBS affiliate WTVF, graduating with a bachelor’s degree in 2018. Memphis mayor Paul Young posted a photo of himself and Keith on Facebook.
“Rest in peace, Tay Keith,” Young wrote.
Entertainment
Jelly Roll, Bunnie Xo divorce: Everything we know about their separation
NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!
Jelly Roll and Bunnie Xo’s split may have shocked fans, but signs of trouble had reportedly been surfacing for months. Bunnie went into detail about her side of the story during a June 18 episode of her podcast, “Dumb Blonde,” in which she cleared up rumors, shed some light on their relationship and revealed some surprising future plans.
Jelly Roll filed for divorce on May 18 in Williamson County, Tennessee, according to court documents obtained by Fox News Digital. The 41-year-old country star listed the date of separation as May 9 and cited irreconcilable differences.
During her podcast, Bunnie shared details about what had transpired ahead of Jelly’s filing, explaining the couple had a fight on Mother’s Day which led to her telling him, “Well, then file the f—ing divorce papers.”
JELLY ROLL’S DAUGHTER CALLS FANS OUT OVER DIVORCE CHATTER AS BUNNIE XO POSTS CRYPTIC SONG LYRICS
“I packed a bag and I left and I didn’t talk to my husband for, I don’t know, weeks after that. And during that, you know, he was so mad, and we were so emotional that he ended up doing exactly what I told him to do, and filing the divorce papers,” she said.
“Was I blindsided and was this divorce mutual? No, I was not. It was not mutual. Even though I told him to file the divorce papers, I was speaking out of anger and just frustration,” she added.
Bunnie spoke about what led to the distance between them on her podcast, revealing the two were trying to have a baby through IVF, which turned her into “a shell of the person I was.”
She revealed that the two underwent three transfers and ultimately lost four embryos, which led to a breakdown in their communication and put a strain on their marriage.
WATCH: JELLY ROLL REVEALS SECRET TO HIS STRONG MARRIAGE TO BUNNIE XO
“We stopped communicating together in the past year and a half,” she shared on the podcast. “And I think that it’s safe for me to say that I always loved my husband a little bit more than he loved me. I was like always protecting him and always making sure he was okay and like always chasing him and I literally was the glue that held us together.”
Despite the divorce, Bunnie said the pair are “still having a baby together.”
“So, we have been the most unconventional couple that you guys have ever encountered,” Bunnie shared. “We’re going to co-parent together. J is my best friend. Like, this isn’t what you guys think this is. Nobody cheated on the other person. It’s literally just we served our purpose for each other.”
During his show in Saratoga Springs, NY on Thursday, Jelly spoke of the “liars” on the internet spreading false rumors about his relationship.
“Me and my wife are best friends. We will always be best friends,” he told the crowd. “We just got off the phone earlier today. Nobody cheated on nobody. She just did a whole podcast about it. You can go watch it. Every word of it is the truth.”
“That will be my best friend forever,” he continued. “This is the only time I will ever speak about it. Bunnie, I love you, baby. Thank you for those ten years. They were incredible. Thank you for the next 10 years of friendship and 20 beyond that.”
The pair, who wed in 2016, have reportedly “always had a complicated dynamic” throughout their relationship.
“When they first got together, they were both in a very different place in their lives,” a source told People. “There was a lot of chaos, ups and downs, and they built a life together through all of that.”
JELLY ROLL’S WIFE SLAMS TROLLS WHO CRITICIZED HER FOR TRASHING COUNTRY MUSIC SCENE
The source noted that Jelly — who has been on a weight-loss journey — has “changed a lot.”
“He’s very focused on his future, his health and being around for a long time,” the source said, adding that “there wasn’t a moment where everything fell apart.”
Other sources claimed that the divorce had been building for years.
JELLY ROLL’S WIFE BLASTS TROLLS WHO QUESTION HER FAITH AFTER RECEIVING BACKLASH FOR SKIMPY HALLOWEEN COSTUME
“A lot of people want to point to one thing, but it was really a combination of issues that had been building for years,” a source told Page Six. “They came from similar worlds when they met and bonded over surviving difficult circumstances, but over time their lives started moving in different directions.”
“Jelly has changed tremendously over the last few years. His focus shifted to his health, faith, family and the long-term legacy he wants to leave behind,” the source added.
WATCH: JELLY ROLL CONFESSES BIGGEST CHALLENGE OF LOSING WEIGHT
Prior to the announcement of the split, fans noticed they’d both seemingly sent subtle messages via social media. From cryptic song lyrics to ditched wedding rings, the signs were there — they just went largely unnoticed.
BUNNIE XO CONFRONTS HER TROUBLED PAST IN RAW MUGSHOT REVEAL ON SOCIAL MEDIA
On May 20, two days after Jelly Roll’s filing, Bunnie took to TikTok to share some intuitive thoughts.
“Women’s intuition when that s— don’t add up” she captioned the video.
JELLY ROLL’S WIFE BODY SLAMS HIM IN PLAYFUL TIKTOK VIDEO AFTER SINGER SHEDS 200 POUNDS
“She been dropping hints this whole time and we missed it lol,” one fan commented, after the divorce news broke.
“Bunnie was dropping the tea in real time and we all did not clock it,” another added.
On June 4, Jelly Roll performed at CMA Fest in Nashville without his wedding ring.
One day later, Bunnie shared a video of herself riding a horse in the countryside. She accompanied the video with Aerosmith’s “What It Takes” and a caption that read, “Wild hearts can’t be broken.”
The lyrics from the portion of the song she chose were, “There goes my old girlfriend / There’s another diamond ring / And all those late night promises I guess they don’t mean a thing / So baby, what’s the story? Did you find another man?”
WATCH: JELLY ROLL AND BUNNIE XO WALK THE RED CARPET TOGETHER AT THE 2025 ACM AWARDS
JELLY ROLL ADMITS TO CHEATING ON WIFE BUNNIE XO IN RARE PUBLIC CONFESSION
On June 6, Bunnie posted another video of herself enjoying the serene outdoors with some girlfriends. She paired the video with lyrics from the Goo Goo Dolls’ hit “Name.”
“Did you lose yourself somewhere out there / Did you get to be a star? / And don’t it make you sad to know that life / Is more than who we are?”
Hours before the divorce news went public on Monday, Bunnie posted a video of herself lip-syncing the lyrics to Nickelback’s “How You Remind Me.” Bunnie’s wedding ring was visibly missing.
“It’s not like you didn’t know that / I said, ‘I love you,’ and I swear, I still do / And it must have been so bad / ‘Cause living with me must have damn near killed you.”
Fans quickly added meaning to Bunnie’s post, with rumors swirling online that she was having an affair with Nickelback founding member, Chad Kroeger, a claim she denied on the podcast.
“I post a Nickelback song because Nickelback is like one of my favorite bands…I post this Nickelback song, not thinking anything of it. Not a shot at J in any sort of way, not even realizing that it’s a breakup song. It’s trending on TikTok,” she said, also acknowledging the other videos she posted involving the band.
“So there’s three f—ing videos…which it does look like overkill, and I get where people are trying to put puzzle pieces together, but you’re putting a puzzle together with missing pieces, and it’s not even like that. I am not with Daddy Chaddy. There’s no f—ing way in hell that that would even be a thing. And no, I did not cheat on my husband and leave him for Chad. Like none of that.”
Representatives for Jelly Roll and Bunnie Xo have not responded to Fox News Digital’s requests for comment.
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR THE ENTERTAINMENT NEWSLETTER
This isn’t the first time the pair have weathered tough times. In her memoir, “Stripped Down: Unfiltered and Unapologetic,” Bunnie detailed her husband’s 2018 affair and explained how it impacted their relationship.
“When I found out about [Jelly’s affair], I was devastated,” she told Fox News Digital in February. “I was hurt because I didn’t think he would be the one person to do that. I thought he was different. And at that moment, my heart was broken. But instead of getting mad at him, I asked myself, ‘Why do I keep attracting these kinds of men?’”
LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? CLICK HERE FOR MORE ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
Bunnie admitted she hadn’t envisioned a conventional marriage.
“I think a lot of people need to realize that coming into this marriage, we weren’t a traditional bride and groom,” she explained. “I was a working girl, and he was an ex-drug dealer — a gangster-turned-struggling artist. There’s a different set of rules on the street than there are in what I’d call traditional marriages. If you’ve never lived that lifestyle, you’re not going to understand. But of course, cheating is wrong across the board — it doesn’t matter.”
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
In 2018, Bunnie shared her vulnerability on social media amid the breakup.
“I’m sure by now you guys know that J and I have separated,” she said in a YouTube video. “It’s been hard and for the best. I’m not going to talk about why we separated. He has his version, I have my version and hopefully one day we’ll be able to be friends.”
“My whole point of doing this vlog is to have a little bit of therapeutic release,” she added. “Everybody goes through heartbreak at some point in their life … I’m a f—ing hot mess. I literally can’t make it through the day with wanting to cry… break ups f—ing suck.”
While Bunnie isn’t quite ready to date yet, she shared on her podcast that Jelly Roll has already started seeing other people.
“He is ready, rearing and ready to go,” she said. “He’s all hopped up on testosterone, let me tell you. Um, and he’s ready to go. So, he’s even started dating, which is great. I love that. Um, so his DMs are open. Go to freaking his Instagram, uh, JellyRoll615 if you don’t know, and go send that mother f—er a DM. Like, you guys don’t be scared. Everybody go hit him up. Shoot your mother f—ing shot.”
-
Business6 days ago
How much of Musk’s wealth comes from government help? Virtually all of it
-
Politics1 week ago
What to know about the stabbing that set off fiery riots in Northern Ireland
-
LifestyleNews2 weeks ago
120 minutes of strength training per week may help extend lifespan
-
Video7 days ago
Download fans say what they love about the festival. #DownloadFestival #BBCNews
-
Video7 days ago
Why SpaceX IPO isn't about space. #SpaceX #ElonMusk #BBCNews
-
HealthNews1 week ago
The people of Okinawa, Japan only eat until they are about 80 percent full, then stop — and the practice has been linked in multiple peer-reviewed studies to lower rates of cardiovascular disease, slo
-
TravelNews7 days ago
My Paternal Instinct Should’ve Warned Me About Netflix’s Maternal Instinct
-
Food7 days ago
Pope Leo’s plane was grounded. Then the King of Spain stepped in to help